top of page

What's going on with 'our' Green Belt?

2 days ago
5 min read

Updated: 4 hours ago

The LANCE Trust has created an interactive map that compares three varying government assessments of Long Ashton's local 'Green Belt'.


A snapshot of the layers of the map
A snapshot of the layers of the map

Until recently, the Green Belt status covered all the land around Long Ashton, Dundry, Barrow Gurney and Flax Bourton. It also protects those who live in South Bristol and the area is known for its tranquillity and proximity to nature with plenty of footpaths meandering through woodland and along watercourses making it an appealing place for many residents who have consistently valued it highly in local consultations.


However, the Green Belt both here and nationwide is also the subject of a bitter controversy with some believing it is ‘too rigid’ in the face of the need for more development and others opposed to any changes (see reasons below).


Three inconsistent Green Belt definitions


With changes in the National Planning Policy Framework (August 2026) driven by the current Government the status of ‘our’ bit of Green Belt has changed. With the national policy changes, North Somerset Council (along with others in England) have had to re-assess the parcels of land within the ‘old’ Green Belt status. Starting from 2021 with the latest in 2026, each of the three assessments are slight different. Yet the Trust has not been able to find a map that puts all three re-assessments into one simple visual context.

  • Strategic Green Belt Assessment NSC April 2021, view more here

  • Strategic Green Belt Assessment WECA May October 2025 (Stage 1: Arup), view more 

  • Strategic Green Belt Assessment NSC May 2026 (Stage 2), view more here


Since the status of the Green Belt matters to many people, the Trust has created a map to put all three re-assessments in one place:


Click the image above to view the page with the map
Click the image above to view the page with the map

Before reviewing the map, it's worth remembering that the original concept of 'grey belt' was introduced as a measure to enable building on poor quality Green Belt such as old car parks, abandoned petrol stations and scrubby wasteland. Made by another local group in 2022, this video, Woodspring Revealed shows that this large plot of land cannot be described as 'wasteland' or even 'suburban' as those working for Taylor Wimpey have described it. Indeed, the latest re-assessment of this site by North Somerset Council retains it as ‘moderate’ Green Belt.


So, if by a miracle, it was to be retained, the Woodspring site has the potential to be enhanced and play an invaluable part in reducing the harms caused by climate change and biodiversity loss. And as the video concludes, "the stakes couldn't be higher". So, what is going on? First it's worth looking at the history of the Green Belt...


The history of the Green Belt


In 1875 Octavia Hill, the founder of the National Trust, was the first to use the phrase 'Green Belt' and the term was legally established in 1947 with  the Green Belt Policy designed is to prevent urban sprawl by keeping land permanently open. The Green Belt was seen not only to protect the countryside around large towns and cities but also give opportunities for local food growing, forestry and outdoor leisure. However, since the 1970's, the effects of climate change and biodiversity loss have increasingly been felt with the adverse impacts of both accelerating fast in the last decade. At the same time, controversy has risen over the Green Belt. For some, the Green Belt is seen as an impediment to growth. Others value the Green Belt highly both in their local areas and further afield witnessing that this necklace of protected areas offers cooling highly urbanised areas, mopping up air pollution and reducing noise pollution.


The economic argument to retain the Green Belt


In 2015, a Senior Government Advisor, Prof Sir Dieter Helm published a paper 'In Defence of the Green Belt'. In this paper, dismisses these assertions and points out that the proposal to build on the Green Belt is based on flawed arguments. And with reference to the planning law processes, he states "It is amazing that there is no serious consideration of the alternatives". As an economist and Fellow of New College, Oxford, his arguments are based on the economic value of retaining the Green Belt and improving it. His conclusion states "A much more environmentally benign agriculture, much greater public access, woodlands located next to people so it could fulfil not only the original purpose of limiting the sprawl but also provide the lungs of the cities, the fresh air for children to play in, and the recreational benefits which are crucial to health and well being. That is worth exploring before the irreversible destruction of this major asset located exactly where it is needed – next to people. There is after all no shortage of land to build houses on if that is what is required. It does not have to be at the expense of a key asset that the previous generation left to us, and which we have a responsibility to pass onto the next generation."


The National Emergency Briefing


In 2025, the National Emergency Briefing set out the evidence on the climate and nature crisis in a formal briefing to national decision-makers. 


The goal is to reset the national conversation and secure a government-led televised emergency briefing from independent experts - an essential first step towards the emergency action now needed. Since then, this briefing has been adapted into a film for public release: the People’s Emergency Briefing and has been shown in Long Ashton, Dundry, Barrow Gurney and many other places in North Somerset, Bristol and Somerset. Having seen the film and with it's charitable aims of maintaining and increasing biodiversity within the parish of Long Ashton and beyond, the Trust fully supports Prof Sir Dieter's Helm's conclusion.


The Woodspring proposed development


It's not just the LANCE Trust and others that find the difference between the Stage 1 and Stage 2 Assessments baffling. Alder King, on behalf of the University of Bristol, has put in a strong statement generally supporting the release of Woodspring land allocations from the Green Belt but point out inconsistencies within the recent Assessments by WECA and NSC in their Response to the Inspectors' questions on NSC's Local Plan 2041:


2.12  "We (Alder King) firstly question the robustness of this approach to not assess the proposed allocation as a whole within the context of Green Belt contribution in the Green Belt Assessment. Secondly by comparison, our client’s land (Fenswood Farm) is assessed in the evidence base (WECA's Re-assessment) to make either a lesser or equal contribution to each of the Green Belt purposes, with an overall assessment result of ‘weak’, as opposed to all four parcels making up the proposed allocation site (the 'Woodspring' site) scoring a higher ‘moderate’ overall result. Moreover, notably within the proposed allocation the ‘land south of A38’ parcel (Dundry slopes) was assessed to make a strong contribution to Green Belt purpose (a). The Council’s Stage 2 Green Belt Assessment finds that this parcel would potentially not meet the definition of grey belt. By comparison, the assessment concludes that our client’s land (Fenswood Farm) would potentially meet the definition of grey belt."


Therefore, as the Public Inspectors examine the soundness of North Somerset's Local Plan 2041, the Trust has included Prof Sir Dieter Helm's conclusion in its Statement to the Examination in Public with reference the release of Woodspring and surrounding areas for development. The Trust's Statement can be found here.


There’s still time to put in an objection highlighting these points on Taylor Wimpey’s dismal Outline Planning Application. More details here.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page